Understand Your Business Objectives Before Drafting
Before you even mention SEO RFP, anchor your process in clarity about why you’re investing in SEO in the first place. Business objectives—such as increasing qualified leads, boosting e-commerce transactions, or enhancing brand visibility—must steer your request. For example, if your company sells enterprise software, the SEO strategy should prioritize high-intent B2B keywords that attract decision-makers, not just generate broad traffic.
Image source: pexels.com
To execute this, start with stakeholder interviews across sales, marketing, and leadership teams. Gather insights about revenue goals, target markets, competitive threats, and customer pain points. Translate these into measurable SEO KPIs. If a goal is to grow organic leads by 30% in a year, specify that in your RFP so vendors understand the performance benchmarks they’ll be held to.
Additionally, examine your analytics data to identify where organic traffic is contributing—or falling short—across your funnel. Document these gaps in the RFP to attract agencies skilled in solving your specific business problems rather than offering generic SEO solutions.
Specify Your Technical SEO Needs
Many companies underestimate how technical complexities can derail SEO performance. Your RFP should detail any technical environments, platforms, or issues the vendor must address. For instance, if your website runs on a custom CMS with limited SEO controls, disclose this early so vendors can assess feasibility and costs.
List existing pain points like slow page speed, crawl budget issues, or JavaScript rendering challenges. For example, an e-commerce brand might note that thousands of dynamically generated product pages are currently invisible to Google. Include details such as server setups, integrations (e.g., with Shopify or Salesforce), and multilingual or international SEO needs.
To execute this, have your web team perform a preliminary technical audit. Summarize the top challenges and include them as a dedicated section in your RFP. This ensures proposals come back realistic and tailored, avoiding surprise costs and scope creep later on.
Define Content Strategy Expectations
Content is the linchpin of any SEO initiative. Yet many RFPs vaguely mention “content marketing” without defining scope. Be specific about the type of content that matters to your business. For example, a SaaS brand might prioritize in-depth blog articles, use cases, and gated white papers targeting C-suite buyers.
Explain your current content landscape. Do you have an in-house writing team that just needs guidance, or do you require vendors to produce content end-to-end? Share examples of existing content that performs well, as well as gaps you hope to fill. For instance, if you lack authoritative pieces on new industry trends, highlight this as a priority.
Executing this involves conducting a content audit. Identify which pages drive traffic, which convert users, and which underperform. Use tools like SEMrush or Screaming Frog to pull data. Include key insights in your RFP to help vendors propose meaningful content strategies instead of cookie-cutter plans.
Insist on Clear Measurement and Reporting
One of the biggest mistakes businesses make in SEO procurement is failing to demand clear reporting structures. Your RFP should explicitly request how vendors will measure performance tied to business outcomes, not just vanity metrics. For instance, instead of simply asking for keyword rankings, ask how those rankings drive form fills or sales pipeline value.
Provide examples of the reporting cadence you expect—monthly, quarterly, or real-time dashboards. State which tools you prefer (e.g., Google Looker Studio, Tableau) and the specific metrics you care about, like organic share of voice, revenue influenced by organic search, or average order value from SEO service channels.
To implement this, review your internal reporting systems and decide where SEO data should plug in. Include these technical requirements in your RFP. This ensures your chosen agency can deliver reports that resonate with your executives and support ROI discussions.
Request Strategic Input, Not Just Execution
An effective SEO RFP isn’t just a task list—it’s an invitation for strategic partnership. Rather than merely requesting deliverables like “X pages optimized per month,” ask vendors to explain how they’ll help achieve your business goals. For example, ask how they’ll prioritize initiatives to generate the fastest ROI or how they’d navigate sudden Google algorithm updates affecting your sector.
Seek examples of how prospective vendors have tackled similar challenges for other clients. For instance, an agency might share a case study where they boosted an e-commerce brand’s organic revenue by restructuring site architecture and implementing content clusters.
To execute this, include scenario-based questions in your RFP. For example: “If our rankings drop 40% overnight, outline your immediate steps.” This filters out vendors who only follow checklists from those who think strategically and can protect your business interests.
Clarify Budget and Resource Constraints
Transparency about budget is crucial to attract proposals that fit your capabilities. Many businesses fear revealing their numbers, assuming it weakens their negotiating position. But hiding budgets often leads to mismatched proposals. For instance, a $10,000 monthly budget won’t secure the same level of service as a $50,000 budget—and agencies need to know where they stand.
Define whether your budget includes content creation, development fixes, link-building, or only consulting. For example, a retail brand might have an internal content team but no development resources, shifting more budget to technical vendor support.
To implement this, outline budget ranges in your RFP and specify how funds should be allocated across services. This invites agencies to tailor proposals creatively while keeping solutions realistic.
Include Evaluation Criteria and Timelines
Finally, make it easy for vendors to understand how their proposals will be judged. Define criteria such as relevant industry experience, proposed methodologies, pricing, and team expertise. For instance, if your business operates in healthcare, you may weigh HIPAA compliance and medical content expertise heavily.
Provide a timeline for submissions, evaluations, and expected project kickoff. A clear schedule signals professionalism and attracts high-quality vendors who can align resources to your deadlines.
To execute this, create a matrix listing each evaluation factor and its relative weight. Include this matrix in your RFP. For example, you might allocate 30% of your decision to strategic approach, 20% to past results, 20% to pricing, and so on. This prevents subjective evaluations and ensures decisions are business-focused.
By building your SEO RFP around business priorities, technical realities, and clear expectations, you’ll transform it from a document about keywords into a strategic tool for driving measurable capital growth.
